Tony Hinchcliffe beat Doug Polk for $20,000 in a bar. Now they meet on the Big Game

Tony Hinchcliffe holding a microphone on a comedy club stage

Tony Hinchcliffe on stage in August 2017. Photo: Lisa Gansky from New York, NY, USA / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

Tony Hinchcliffe was drunk in an Austin bar in 2025 when he challenged Doug Polk to heads-up poker for $20,000. Polk is a poker pro. Twenty minutes later the comedian had his money.

Then Hinchcliffe made the offer that turned a bar story into a TV pitch. “Since it had only been 20 minutes, I said, ‘I’ll tell you what, even though I won, let’s double or nothing,’” he recalled. The new bet was $40,000, and the game was no longer poker. Polk had to do a minute of stand-up comedy.

Show

Big Game on Tour, Season 3

Runs

Weekly to December 6

Loose Cannon stake

$50,000

Hands to profit

150

The poker player who won a comedy bet

Polk won the rematch. Hinchcliffe, host of the Kill Tony podcast, then put him on the show. Polk opened his set with: “It’s hard to live in Texas without hearing about the immigration debate.” Hinchcliffe’s review: “Absolutely incredible, when you put your mind to it. You’ve been practicing for a month.”

Both men live in Austin. Now they sit at the same table again, this time with cameras on. Season 3 of the PokerStars Big Game on Tour premieres this Sunday and runs weekly through December 6.

The table

Hinchcliffe makes his Big Game debut next to Polk, Antonio Esfandiari, Esther Taylor and reality TV star Princess Love. Esfandiari plays only now and then these days. Last season he sat with Phil Hellmuth and NFL legend Rob Gronkowski.

The Loose Cannon

This season’s Loose Cannon is comedian Scott Gaughan, who hosts comedy game shows. He gets $50,000 to play with, and he keeps nothing unless he is in profit after 150 hands.

So the table has two comedians, one with a $20,000 win over Polk already on his record, and a poker pro who has already won a comedy bet. Who walks away with the money this time: the comedians, or the man who learned stand-up to beat one?

Telegram X Facebook